I still love GW2. The graphics are really great. I used to think the landscape in LOTRO was better, but after exploring in GW2, I definitely no longer think that. The graphics in GW2 are far better.
LOTRO just came out with their "expansion" today, and I have a lifetime account with that game, but haven't played it the past 3 months and can't even motivate myself to play it again after having played GW2.
I don't love the LOTRO game like I do the movie.